Everyone at Halcyon High knew Ava Sterling.
She wasn’t just popular—she was the kind of popular that never looked earned, only deserved. Her locker was always decorated, her test scores always perfect, and her friends always perfectly placed in photos like a magazine layout.
Captain of the debate team.
President of three clubs.
Straight-A student.
Volunteer of the month—every month.
Prom queen, sophomore year.
Sophomore year.
If you were near Ava, you smiled. You agreed. You supported. You posted kind things about her online, even when you didn’t mean it. Because Ava wasn’t just admired. She was respected. Trusted.
Feared.
Not overtly. No one ever called her a bully. She never shouted. Never made a scene. Never needed to. Ava had a gift: she didn’t control people with force. She used suggestion, like slipping poison into a glass of water and watching someone drink it on their own.
She didn’t rise to the top. She built the top and invited herself to live there.
You never saw her without her signature red planner—color-coded, post-it stacked, sealed with gold stickers and the scent of lavender. If you were in that planner, your life would go well. If you weren’t?
Well.
Better smile harder.
Senior year was her year. She had already been courted by top universities. The principal asked her opinion before changing the school lunch schedule. She didn’t just rule the school—she curated it. Ava’s final act would be her pièce de résistance: the annual fall play.
She’d produce it. Direct it. Star in it. It was the perfect setup. Her face on every poster. Her name in every announcement. And the play she picked?
“The Glorious Rise” —a hero’s journey about a noble girl who saves a broken school from chaos, corruption, and scandal.
Subtle, right?
She rewrote the second act herself.
Then… he showed up.
Milo Ray.
Transfer student.
Junior.
Messy hair. Always sketching something. Wore band shirts no one recognized. Looked like he hadn’t made eye contact since 2009. Most students didn’t even notice him.
Ava did.
He walked into the stage crew meeting late, said nothing, sat down, and started doodling in the margins of the production script. The first day he touched a prop, he reassembled the whole set design without asking.
She gave him a warning smile.
“We usually stick to the script here.”
He blinked at her. No fear. Just mild boredom.
“Yours is a little… flat. I thought I’d make it more interesting.”
No one had ever talked to her like that. She didn’t even know how to respond.
She told the crew to keep an eye on him. Told the costume team to avoid taking direction from him. But every time she tried to edge him out, something weird happened.
The crew started liking him.
He didn’t suck up. He didn’t command. But he listened. Asked questions. Joked with the lighting techs. Quietly fixed mistakes Ava hadn’t even noticed. Soon, people who never challenged her began checking in with him.
And Ava noticed something else: the script was changing.
Not on paper—she kept it locked in her planner.
But in practice.
Scenes she’d crafted to spotlight her greatness started… mutating. Lines were being altered. Tone shifted. Her shining monologues suddenly felt ironic. Audience reactions during rehearsals turned strange—laughter where there should’ve been awe. Applause during lines she hadn’t highlighted.
And somehow, Milo was always around when it happened.
Ava confronted him one afternoon in the auditorium.
He was sitting alone, sketching in the wings.
“What are you doing to my play?”
He looked up. Smiled slightly.
“Your play? I thought it was a school production.”
She stepped closer.
“Don’t play dumb with me. You’ve been changing things. Turning the cast against me.”
He tilted his head, like a cat watching a vacuum cleaner.
“You sure you didn’t do that part yourself?”
She opened her mouth—but couldn’t find a response. Not because he was right. He wasn’t. Obviously. But because, for just a second, the mask cracked.
She felt it.
That sick little thing inside her. The one she kept buried under perfect grades and photos and speeches. The thing that wasn’t interested in applause but in obedience.
Milo saw it.
And that’s when she understood: he knew what she was.
He wasn’t just some weird art kid. He was the only one who saw the monster in the crown.
She reported him. Told the theater teacher Milo was undermining the production. Planting toxic ideas. Being disruptive.
But nothing stuck.
He was too slippery. Too vague. Too careful.
And besides—Milo never said anything openly. Never made demands. Just kept drawing. Sketching sets, characters, rewriting the entire tone of the play—one quiet whisper at a time.
The crew started referring to the main character by her stage name sarcastically. “The Saint of Halcyon.”
They didn’t think Ava heard.
She heard everything.
The auditorium was packed.
Ava stood in the wings, stage makeup flawless, costume glowing under the lights. This was supposed to be her moment. Her speech in the final act was ten minutes long—a tearful, triumphant declaration of her sacrifices and brilliance.
But something felt off.
The lighting cues were… colder. Harsher. The music sounded more like a funeral march than a heroic swell. The scenes leading up to her speech had been rearranged, somehow. Dialogue she hadn’t written made the audience laugh—not with her, but at her.
She came onstage anyway. Powered through the speech.
But the words didn’t land.
Because Milo had won.
Every choice—the music, the tone, the acting, the editing—had turned her grand moment into a dark satire. Instead of watching a triumphant hero rise… the audience watched a self-obsessed, manipulative control freak spiral into delusion.
When the curtain fell, the applause wasn’t for her.
It was for the cast. The lighting. The clever twists.
And somewhere, backstage, Milo smiled. Packed up his sketches. Fist-bumped the tech crew. Then walked out into the night without ever taking a bow.
Ava tried to regain control.
She gave interviews. Posted perfect photos. Thanked everyone graciously.
But it didn’t work this time.
People laughed when they mentioned the play. Said it was smart. Unexpected. “So brave of you to play the villain,” one girl said, thinking it was a compliment.
Ava didn’t respond.
She opened her planner. Scribbled out her schedule. Rewrote her college essay. Avoided the theater. She felt her empire crumbling—not loudly, but in the subtle, permanent way a structure does when the foundation rots.
As for Milo?
No one saw him again.
He transferred two weeks later. Left behind a single thing in the costume closet: a sketchbook.
Inside it, every page was filled with drawings.
Not of Ava.
Of The Hero.
The real one.
Crowned in shadows.
Smiling too perfectly.
Built from charm and cruelty.
Manipulating everyone.
On the last page, scrawled in crooked handwriting:
“Every story needs a villain.
And sometimes, they write their own.”
Add comment
Comments